A 2008 study directed by rebecca moore howard, professor of writing and rhetoric at syracuse. This student handbook serves as a comprehensive guide to writing style and mechanics as well as research methods. All patchwriting is a kind of paraphrase, but successful paraphrase is not. Many cite the work of rebecca moore howard coeditor of one of the new books on plagiarism and a contributor to another, who is an associate professor of writing and rhetoric at syracuse university. Jessa wood, ted roggenbuck, peter doerschler, megan hicks. Sep 18, 2012 a 2008 study directed by rebecca moore howard, professor of writing and rhetoric at syracuse university, suggests that much of the writing by college students is intellectually dishonest, but. By rebecca moore howard november 16, 2001 premium content for subscribers.
Oct 08, 2012 devoss and rosati view the comments and writings of other scholars, in the topic of plagiarism. Patchwriting was coined by professor rebecca moore howard in 1993, with description of copying. Apr 07, 2008 many cite the work of rebecca moore howard coeditor of one of the new books on plagiarism and a contributor to another, who is an associate professor of writing and rhetoric at syracuse university. Defines a form of source usage called patchwriting that relies heavily on summary and which. Rebecca moore howard is the author of writing matters 3. Jul 24, 2015 the term most commonly used in the usa is patchwriting, although the definition of that term is not fixed and neither is the classification of patchwriting as plagiarism. Expanding on diane pecoraris study 2003 of the ways nonnative speakers of english incorporate. Reading rebecca moore howards article caused me to rethink my own ideas about plagiarism a bit, i must admit. Moreover, howard argues that patchwriting can be viewed as the natural outcome of the. Find all the books, read about the author, and more. Howard argues that patchwriting splicing chunks of text together with some word substitutions is natural and perhaps even unavoidable for nonnative speakerswriters and even nongenrenative writers, such as a sociologist writing about astrophysics.
Rebecca moore howards theories started to make more sense to me. Writing matters focuses the rules and conventions of writing through a lens of responsibility, ultimately empowering students to own their ideas. Writing matters by rebecca moore howard home facebook. Reread the source, this time a little more slowly to get details. Howard, standing in the shadow of giants revolution lullabye. For more about their findings from an analysis of 18 student papers, see rebecca moore howard, tricia c. Sandra jamieson and rebecca moore howard have defined it. Sandra jamieson and rebecca moore howard smart talk project.
Aug 06, 20 rebecca moore howards theories started to make more sense to me. A 2008 study directed by rebecca moore howard, professor of writing and rhetoric at syracuse university, suggests that much of the writing by. Nov 25, 2014 cheating non attribution of sources patchwriting howard, rebecca moore. Or the student understands what she is reading but is new to the discourse. Sandra jamieson and rebecca moore howard direct the citation project, a national study providing open access empirical data about how college students use sources when writing papers for composition courses. Chris hedges accused of plagiarism by the new republic and harpers.
Childrens early speech consists mostly of lexical or open class words. Miller ask whether spoken words are bound to the same citing rules as writing, and finally maureen hourigan writes about the problem of paper. A plagiarism pentimento rebecca moore howard two different acts are considered plagiarism. When she discussed the idea of patchwriting as something that is a normal part of a students learning process, i agreed with her, but only to a certain extent. Finding sources if you need help figuring out where to look for this kind of definition. Plagiarisms, authorships, and the academic death penalty. Now if the book was available through ibooks and the connect website worked on the ipad that would be even better meaning 5 stars. Nov 16, 2001 by rebecca moore howard november 16, 2001 premium content for subscribers. Rebecca moore howard 1993 defined patchwriting as copying from a source text and then deleting some words, altering grammatical structures, or plugging in.
Guiding students from cheating and plagiarism to honesty and integrity. This often happens at the onset of twoword speaking. Plagiarisms, authorships, and the academic death penalty rebecca moore howard i n composition studies, most published discussions of student plagiarism pro ceed from the assumption that plagiarism occurs as a result of one of two pos sible motivations. Rebecca moore howard 2001, who coined the term patchwriting. Plagiarism and patchwriting detection in efl students. A 2008 study directed by rebecca moore howard, professor of writing and rhetoric at syracuse university, suggests that much of the writing by college students is. For this reason, standard definitions of plagiarism are of little use to teachers. In pils interview, the researchers say of their latest results. Rebecca moore howard 2001, who coined the term patchwriting, states that patchwriting comes from uneven reading comprehension. For a number of years now, howard has been arguing that we need to rethink the criminalization of the type of plagiarism involving copying pieces of texts.
Howard advances a new theory of authorship that contests current understandings of plagiarism and the construction of the studentplagiaristcriminal. In order to navigate out of this carousel please use your heading shortcut key to navigate. Also contained in the handbook are overviews of mla, apa, and chicago writing style and documentation. Writing matters by rebecca moore howard posts facebook. Rebecca moore howard 2001, who coined the term patchwriting, states that. Sandra jamieson and rebecca moore howard have defined it as. Meaning that to her, the act is merely a manner in which the students borrow ideas and use them to complete their own ideas. Patchwriting academic writing in english, lund university. Using others ideas or words without acknowledging the authors or citing the sources properly, intentionally or not, is considered cheating and known as plagiarism. Jul 20, 2015 rebecca moore howard has shown that patchwritingweaving the language of one or more source texts into ones own text without adequately citing the sourcesis a common form of developmental plagiarism. Sandra jamieson and rebecca moore howard smart talk.
Cccc statement on second language writing and writers. Rebecca moore howard has shown that patchwritingweaving the language of one or more source texts into ones own text without adequately citing the sourcesis a common form of developmental plagiarism. Plagiarisms, authorships, and the academic death penalty jstor. Devoss and rosati view the comments and writings of other scholars, in the topic of plagiarism. Noting the wpa claim that many discussions of plagiarism fail to observe the distinctions in its definition and arguing that intention can be hard to discern in actual student behavior, hartwig addresses rebecca moore howards concept of patchwriting, in which students incompletely translate source material into their own words. An exercise in patchwriting christopher leary rebecca moore howard defines patchwriting as a method of composing in which writers take the words of other authors and patch them together with few or no changes 233. Patchwriting is more common than plagiarism, just as dishonest. Every blog, including rebecca moore howard s noticed that the old, vintage fashion is finding a way back into the modern european fashion trends and on the fashion shows. Plagiarism and promiscuity, authors and plagiarisms 31. But some closed class or function words also appear fairly early. Conference presentation at cccc, atlanta, 2011, later published as rebecca moore howard and sandra jamieson, researched writing in a guide to composition pedagogies.
Rebecca moore howard writes an essay describing the reason why a student would closely paraphrase a work, while keith d. In western academia, intellectual property is highly protected. For prof accusing gorsuch, plagiarism is tantamount to rape. I take issue with the definition of plagiarism offered in diana.
Patchwriting example can you spot the similarities. Patchwriting involves copying from a source text then deleting some words, altering grammatical structures, or plugging in onetoone synonymsubstitutes. Rebecca moore howard, a researcher with years of experience and scholarly credentials in com. A study of student source use by rebecca moore howard, tricia serviss, and tanya k. Rebecca moore howard author visit amazons rebecca moore howard page. How else can one explain giving the same paper assignment semester after semester to a lecture class of 100. Prof who accused neil gorsuch of plagiarism once compared. If your focus is on procedure and correct format, these papers are a great success. Further, patchwriting, defined by rebecca moore howard, as the copying of sections of texts, such as phrasings and sentence patterns, is a natural part of the process of learning to write in a. Read the source once through, quickly, perhaps reading only the first sentence of each paragraph if there are several or more paragraphs. The politico article quoted rebecca moore howard, a writing and rhetoric professor at syracuse university, who accused gorsuch of patchwriting which the citation project defines as.
The term most commonly used in the usa is patchwriting, although the definition of that term is not fixed and neither is the classification of patchwriting as plagiarism. Although associated with plagiarism, it is an extremely useful writing strategy with a very. Cheating non attribution of sources patchwriting howard, rebecca moore. Reconsidering the role of the pedagogical context in esl student writers. In a 1993 article, she proposed the following definition. Try these steps with an article or passage you want to summarize. Rebecca moore howard, an assistant professor in the department of. Follow rebecca moore howard and explore their bibliography from s rebecca moore howard author page. Pdf plagiarism and patchwriting detection in efl students. English and writing professors sandra jamieson and rebecca moore howard have defined it as restating a phrase, clause, or one or more.
Addressing misconceptions about plagiarism in writing by l2 writers by lan wanghiles. Patchwriting, a term she coins for writertext collaboration likened to imitation. Plagiarism, paraphrase, summary linkedin slideshare. Chris hedges accused of plagiarism by the new republic and. Unlike what often seems to be common belief, plagiarism cannot always be clearly defined. A handbook for writing and research by rebecca moore howard online at alibris.
Instead of viewing such concept as negative rebecca moore howard, sees plagiarism as patchwriting and kidnapping. Patchwriting was coined by professor rebecca moore howard in 1993, with description of copying from a source text and then deleting some words, altering grammatical structures, or plugging in oneforone synonymsubstitutes. Plagiarists, authors, collaborators, gives a definite no for an answer. Devoss and rosati summary writing about literature. Rebecca moore howard 1993 defined patchwriting as copying from a source text and then deleting some words, altering grammatical structures, or plugging in oneforone synonym substitutes.
Rebecca moore howard, sandra jamieson, and others working on the citation project, have done much to study and measure students frequently problematic practices when they write from sources. Jun 29, 2018 noting the wpa claim that many discussions of plagiarism fail to observe the distinctions in its definition and arguing that intention can be hard to discern in actual student behavior, hartwig addresses rebecca moore howards concept of patchwriting, in which students incompletely translate source material into their own words. Rebecca howards new book, standing in the shadow of giants. Mar 27, 2011 reading rebecca moore howards article caused me to rethink my own ideas about plagiarism a bit, i must admit. As scholarly understanding of the ways students engage with sources has developed since.
To help students, ive written a college writers handbook, writing matters. Howard talks about patchwriting as a common undergraduate technique of grouping together various sources. For that work, they define patchwriting as restating a phrase, clause, or one or. Customers who bought this item also bought these digital items. In fact, you can easily notice how pastel colors, which were famous back in the sixties are coming back to life, and not just in clothes fashion, but in interior design as well. Addressing misconceptions about plagiarism in writing by. Johnsoneilola and selber also refer to a 1993 article by rebecca moore howard on patchwriting, which describes a technique used by new authors. The politico article quoted rebecca moore howard, a writing and rhetoric professor at syracuse university, who accused gorsuch of patchwriting which the citation project defines. Rebecca moore howard is an associate professor of writing and rhetoric, and director of. The origin seems to be in rebecca moore howard, a plagiarism pentimento, journal of teaching writing 1993. This shopping feature will continue to load items when the enter key is pressed.
1216 542 617 1002 709 1013 463 599 1400 280 34 884 605 389 326 1009 110 312 492 50 292 120 666 224 193 845 1003 1119 617 821 1210 473 493 668 1249 583